Best Pancake Maple Syrup – Your Buyer’s Guide for 2023

Pancake Maple Syrup

What do you associate with a fluffy plate of pancakes? If you ask me, the first thing that comes to mind is a thick, delectable syrup.

I believe that the sprinkle of sweet syrup is what actually distinguishes pancakes. Don’t you think so? And only the greatest pancake syrups would appeal to a foodie.

So you’ve chosen to purchase a fresh bottle of syrup. However, the grocery shop contains rows and rows of syrups in various tastes and costs. And the variety of pancake syrup brands is driving you dizzy.

Don’t give up too soon! I tested 9 of the best pancake syrups on the market to offer you the best of the best.

Continue reading to learn all you need to know about pancake syrups. I’ve covered everything from different sorts to different tastes to help you pick the best.

So, let’s get started.

ImageProduct NameEditor's RatingPrice

Butternut Mountain Pure Vermont Maple Syrup
Butternut Mountain Pure Vermont Maple Syrup

Check Price

Lakanto Sugar Free Maple Flavored Syrup
Lakanto Sugar Free Maple Flavored Syrup

Check Price

Mrs. Butterworth's Syrup
Mrs. Butterworth's Syrup

Check Price

ChocZero's Maple Syrup for Pancakes
ChocZero's Maple Syrup for Pancakes

Check Price

So Nourished Keto Pancake Syrup
So Nourished Keto Pancake Syrup

Check Price

Types of Pancake Syrup

Types of Pancake Syrup

A stack of pancakes isn’t complete unless it’s drenched in syrup. To pick an excellent pancake syrup, however, you must first understand the many sorts of syrups.

To begin, there are two types of pancake syrup. Organic maple syrup and flavored pancake syrups are available.

Maple Syrup, Organic

Organic maple syrup is created from maple tree sap. They’re high in nutrients, antioxidants, and sugar. Yes, maple syrup contains around 66% sugar.

There are other kinds within this category! All maple syrups are now grade A. They are also separated by color. For more suggestions, you can read about Copper Pots for Candy Making.

Golden Color-Soft Taste:

This maple syrup is made during the early harvest season. It also has the mildest flavor and a lovely golden hue. This complements buttermilk pancakes, ice cream, and fruit salads well.

Amber-Colored Taste:

This one has a strong, rich maple taste. It has a richer taste than the golden one and is ideal for baking.

Dark Color-Strong Taste:

Choose this if you enjoy a rich, powerful maple flavor. It is harvested later in the season. This kind is commonly used in pies, marinades, and glazes. Additionally, you can check our review on Disposable Piping Bags.

Strong Dark Taste:

The most strong maple flavor comes from this syrup. It’s almost molasses-like in its intensity. It is mostly utilized by confectionery manufacturers.

Pancake Syrups with Flavors

Corn syrup is the primary ingredient in flavored syrups. These pancake syrups also contain various flavors, colors, and preservatives. Maple, caramel, and butter are the most popular tastes.

However, healthy syrups replace vegetable, chicory root, or other soluble fibers for corn syrup. These are sweetened with monk fruit, stevia leaf, or erythritol, among other things.

The major advantage of flavored pancake syrups is that they are less expensive than pure maple syrup. You may also choose from Keto, vegan, sugar-free, and low-calorie alternatives.

Top 7 Best Pancake Maple Syrup On The Market in 2023

1. Butternut Mountain Pure Vermont Maple Syrup

When it comes to pancake syrups, I’m a firm believer in pure maple syrup. On pancakes, nothing beats the pure and deep richness of maple syrup.

And what could be better than Vermont maple syrup? Yes, the pure Vermont maple syrup from Butternut Mountain Farm is 100% real.

Decades of maple syrup producing experience is what makes this syrup so excellent. From sap collection through the production of the deeply flavored syrup, every step is taken with great care to bring you this sweet elixir.

If you enjoy the natural maple flavor, this is a must-try. This GRADE A syrup’s strong maple taste makes it the best maple syrup for pancakes.

It will go well with not only pancakes but also a variety of other dishes. It goes well with drinks, morning cereal, fruit salad, roasted vegetables, and grilled meat and fish, to mention a few.

Not to mention the really convenient package. These 32-ounce bottles are remarkably light. As a result, they are simpler to transport and pour.

Not only that, but the packaging is constructed of BPA-free plastic. That is, the flavor remains fresh and pleasant for a longer period of time.

This flexible, low-cost, high-quality maple syrup will satisfy all of your maple syrup demands.

Highlighted features include:

  • This syrup contains minerals and antioxidants.
  • It is a Grade A maple syrup with a deep amber hue.
  • It goes well with a wide range of dishes and beverages.
  • Light maple taste with a natural vanilla undertone.
  • Available in a BPA-free jug for the environment.

2. Lakanto Sugar Free Maple Flavored Syrup

The majority of people enjoy the flavor of classic maple syrup on their pancakes. But, let’s face it, they’re heavy in calories and carbohydrates. As a result, it is unsuitable for anyone attempting to follow a healthy diet.

Are you seeking for a healthy substitute for maple syrup as well? Then stop looking! The Lakanto Maple Flavored Syrup is the most nutritious pancake syrup on the market.

This pancake syrup has no sugar. In reality, non-GMO monk fruit extract is used to sweeten it. So, if you prefer the taste of sugar-free pancake syrup, this is ideal.

Furthermore, you may enjoy the flavor of maple syrup without ingesting a lot of calories. Because it has just one net carb per serving and is fewer in calories than real maple syrup.

Furthermore, this syrup will be excellent for all natural diets. This means that folks on Keto, candida, vegan, paleo, or low carb diets may all enjoy the smooth, delightful flavor of maple.

Not only that, but With this sugar-free syrup, even diabetics may restore the sweetness to their pancakes. And all without raising their glycemic index! With the Lakanto all-natural maple-flavored pancake syrup, you may kickstart your healthy lifestyle.

Highlighted features include:

  • A low-carb and gluten-free pancake syrup.
  • Monk fruit and vegetable fiber that is non-GMO.
  • Supports a variety of eating programs.
  • It doesn’t have any sugar in it.
  • It may be used to sweeten a number of meals.

3. Mrs. Butterworth’s Syrup

Then there’s the pancake syrup, which I’m sure most of us grew up with. Mrs. Butterworth’s Syrup, to be specific.

To be honest, there are a plethora of corn sugar pancake syrups on the market. Mrs. Butterworth’s syrup, on the other hand, stands out from the crowd due to its exceptional flavor.

This syrup has a buttery smooth feel. It even has a hint of honey along with maple flavor, like a cherry on top of the cake.

This syrup’s distinct flavor profile and texture complement pancakes and waffles perfectly. Some users even claim that this is the best waffle syrup.

If you want high-quality pancake syrup, look no further than this. Since 1961, this syrup has made our pancakes delicious.

Furthermore, they use less than 2% artificial preservatives. Many people associate the original packaging with childhood memories. It also enables you to enjoy a delectable slow pour. This 128 ounce of pure joy is an excellent purchase for the entire family.

Highlighted features include:

  • Syrup with maple and honey flavors.
  • Contains high fructose corn syrup.
  • It is well-known for its distinct buttery texture.
  • Each serving has 20 calories.
  • A one-gallon family pack is available.

4. ChocZero’s Maple Syrup for Pancakes

You’re definitely aware of how seductive syrupy sweet maple syrup can be. But we can all agree that eating too much sweet deliciousness is bad for our health.

As a result, many people are seeking for sugar-free substitutes to sweeten their pancakes. ChocZero’s Maple Syrup is a wonderful choice for this.

Many people consider this sugar-free syrup to be the greatest pancake syrup. Do you want to discover what makes it so great?

First and foremost, this syrup has a delectably silky texture. You’ll also get to savor a distinct maple flavor. This is extremely wonderful because of the mix of these ingredients.

And all of this without gaining any weight. Yes, natural vegetable fiber and monk fruit extract are included in this caramelly delight. As a consequence, each serving of this sugar-free syrup has just one gram net carb.

Furthermore, the makers verify that it contains no chemical preservatives, soy, sugar alcohol, or GMOs. As a result, you may be certain in the quality of this syrup.

Another important consideration is the syrup’s thickness. ChocZero’s syrups include no water or fillers. As a result, you may enjoy naturally thick syrup to make every pancake spectacular.

Not to mention that this syrup goes well with more than simply pancakes. You may now restore sweetness to all of your meals without deviating from Keto or low-carb diets.

Highlighted features include:

  • Sucralose-free pancake syrup that is excellent.
  • Naturally sweetened with monk fruit extract.
  • It has a luxuriously thick texture.
  • Excellent for Keto and low carb diets.
  • Does not raise the glycemic index.

5. So Nourished Keto Pancake Syrup

Following the ketogenic diet has several advantages. But it’s also challenging since you have to follow rigorous dietary requirements.

Many people believe that if you start Keto, you must give up delectable pancake syrups. Because maple syrup contains 66% sugar, it is not Keto-friendly.

Fortunately, ‘So Nourished Keto Maple Syrup’ is available. This maple-flavored pancake syrup will allow you to enjoy your pancakes without deviating from your Keto diet.

That isn’t everything. This syrup is suitable for people who follow a vegan, low-sugar, or low-calorie diet. Why? Because each serving of our sugar-free syrup provides just 1g carb and 20 calories.

Sucralose and other artificial sweeteners might have a negative impact on your gut health. However, So Nourished employs natural sweeteners that are good for your intestinal health.

The right sweetness is ensured by the mix of erythritol, monk fruit, and stevia leaf extract. It has the consistency of real maple syrup thanks to the inclusion of erythritol.

In addition, chicory root fiber is used. This prevents your glycemic index from rising. Diabetics might enjoy it with their pancakes. This Keto-friendly syrup allows you to enjoy the sweetness without feeling guilty.

Highlighted features include:

  • This syrup has 9g of fiber per serving.
  • Three natural sweeteners are used to sweeten it.
  • 2 tbsp syrup contains just 20 calories.
  • This syrup is known as a low-glycemic syrup.
  • Excellent for ketogenic and gluten-free diets.

6. Walden Farms Sweet Syrups

Tired of the same syrup on your pancakes? Then this Walden Farms Sweet Syrups five-pack is for you.

Walden Farms has created a bundle of five wonderful flavored pancake syrups to make your breakfast more enjoyable every day. Yes, chocolate, blueberry, strawberry, caramel, and pancake syrups will be available.

You may now flavor your pancake with whatever you desire. Furthermore, these syrups will make fruit salads, parfaits, smoothies, and coffee tastings more fascinating.

These syrups contain no calories at all. These syrups have no sugar, gluten, carbohydrates, or cholesterol. That is, you may enjoy sweet treats while still leading a healthy lifestyle.

Furthermore, the fruity tastes are pure and natural. The colour was also done using natural substances such as purple sweet potato.

Flavored syrups might have an odd aftertaste. However, you will not receive any complaints about this with these syrups. The lack of sugar alcohol eliminates this issue.

For almost 40 years, Walden Farms has been manufacturing nutritious pancake syrups. As a result, you can expect high-quality delicious syrups.

Overall, purchase these syrups if you wish to eat a balanced diet without sacrificing sweetness. They have zero net carbs per serving. This box is a pancake syrup lover’s dream come true.

Highlighted features include:

  • The set includes five different flavors of pancake syrup.
  • There are no calories in any of the syrups.
  • Sucralose is used to sweeten them.
  • FDA approval is included.
  • Increases the diversity of your meals.

7. 365 by WFM Organic Maple Syrup

Honey has less antioxidants and minerals than pure maple syrup. It can also help you develop and maintain your bone health, cell production, and metabolism.

These advantages, however, are only available from pure maple syrup. That is what 365 by WFM Maple Syrup provides.

This maple syrup is prepared entirely from the sap of premium maple trees. As a result, each spoonful of syrup contains minerals such as calcium, potassium, and iron.

This syrup has been verified as 100% organic by the Climate Friendly Pledge. It’s also USDA and QAI approved. As a result, you can be confident that it contains no GMOs or preservatives.

Not only that, but this maple syrup is vegan and fat-free. As a result, you may enjoy the strong black flavor of this syrup guilt-free.

Not to mention the stunning glass bottle packaging of this syrup. This 12-ounce bottle of sweetness is an excellent present for family and friends.

Overall, the real dark maple flavor and smooth texture make this a wonderful pancake and waffle flavor enhancer.

Highlighted features include:

  • Organic maple trees were used to make this product.
  • Each serving has 110 calories.
  • Pledge on Climate Change Product that is user-friendly.
  • This has a dark and powerful maple taste.
  • Vegan and fat-free labels

Pancake Maple Syrup Buying Guide

Best Pancake Maple Syrup


The first decision you must make is the sort of pancake syrup to purchase. Because there are considerations for pure maple syrups that are not essential for flavored syrups.

Do you prefer the traditional maple?

Do you prefer a range of tastes, such as chocolate, caramel, or butter? There are several varieties of pancake syrup on the market. If you’re not sure, you may experiment with mini-sized syrups of various flavors.

Color and Grade

If you’ve decided on pure maple syrup, consider the grade and color. All maple syrup is grade A under the new system. The hue makes a difference in flavor.

The golden tint indicates a mild maple taste. Amber denotes a rich maple flavor. Then comes a dark color with a robust flavor. The dark-colored maple syrup has the most strong maple flavor.


Another factor to consider is how you want to use the maple syrup. The greatest pancake syrups to pair with pancakes and waffles are those with a moderate flavor.

If you plan on grilling or baking, choose a syrup with a stronger maple flavor.


When it comes to pure maple syrup, a higher price does not always imply superior quality. Local farmers sell excellent maple syrup at a significantly lower price. If you want to save money, try purchasing from bulk retailers.

Try Amazon if you want to narrow down hundreds of alternatives based on your budget. Online marketplaces such as Amazon frequently offer fantastic prices with the added convenience of home delivery.


Forget pure maple syrup if you want sugar-free pancake syrup. But don’t despair, since there are some fantastic sugar-free syrup choices on the market right now.

You may select maple-flavored or other flavored syrups that are sweetened naturally. Erythritol, fruit extracts, stevia, and other natural sweeteners are examples.

Choose ones that do not include artificial sweeteners such as sucralose. Because they are not good for your digestion.

Dietary Limitations

Most popular diets limit carbs, GMOs, and artificial additives. So, before you buy any syrup, check the label. Is it made with Keto-friendly, vegan, or natural ingredients?

There are some fantastic Keto, low-calorie, vegan pancake syrups on the market right now. As a result, make your selection based on your preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What Is the Difference Between Dark Maple Syrup and Amber Maple Syrup?

The dark maple syrup has the strongest maple taste. It is mostly used in cooking. The amber syrup, on the other hand, has a rich but less powerful maple flavor. It is preferred in drinks and pancakes.

2. Is Maple Syrup Good for You?

Pure maple syrup is said to be healthier than table sugar. It is also higher in nutrients than honey. However, because maple syrup raises insulin levels, you should use them carefully.

3. How Do Sugar-Free Syrups Get Their Sweetness?

Plant-based or artificial sweeteners can be used to sweeten sugar-free syrups. The most common sugar alcohols are erythritol, sorbitol, and xylitol. Fruit extracts and stevia can also be used to sweeten these syrups.

4. Is Vegan Pancake Syrup Available?

It depends on whatever pancake syrup you’re referring about. Vegan maple syrups are those that are 100% pure and include no preservatives. If the syrup is flavored, check sure it only contains natural flavors and sweeteners.

5. How Do You Make Maple Syrup?

The sap of maple trees is used to make maple syrup. The sap is filtered, cooked, and then flavored and colored. One gallon of maple syrup requires around 40 gallons of sap.

6. Should I keep my maple syrup in the refrigerator?

Unopened maple syrup has a two-year shelf life. It also does not need to be refrigerated. Once the bottle has been opened, it must be refrigerated. When refrigerated, it will keep for a few months.

Last Words

Pancakes and syrups are a pair that isn’t complete without the other. These syrups can also be used in a variety of different recipes. However, the abundance of syrup options makes selecting one difficult.

Hopefully, the evaluations of the finest pancake syrup have assisted you in locating your ideal morning companion.

This list contains both pure and flavored maple syrups. I also talked about items for those with various diets, budgets, and flavor preferences.

So, what are you holding out for? Choose the one that best meets your demands and enjoy your fluffy pancakes with the delectable syrups. I wish you a life filled with honey!